Corrected 2 October 2026 · version 2.0.0. The first version of this site made claims that were wrong. What changed and why · the original, kept
Waste as Resource logo corrected Waste as Resourceversion 2.0.0 · corrected

WASTE
AS RESOURCE

Every day, Wales makes waste that can power homes and fertilise fields. Some of it still ends up in our rivers.

Right now, in Welsh waters

Checking live overflow monitors…

Source: Welsh Water's live overflow status service. Red: operating now. Amber: operated in the last 24 hours. The first version of this site read only the first 2,000 of its 2,362 records; it now reads all of them.

… overflow sites reported how long they spilled in 2024
254,100 cows in Wales's dairy herd, each making about 23 tonnes of slurry a year
£93.8mWelsh Water's power cost, 2024-25
It generates 23% of its own energy. The target was 35%
27.5 GWh of heat from sludge digestion went unused
98.2% of its sludge is digested. We said the opposite. We were wrong.
35,000 tDS of cake is left after digestion, spread on farmland
…
people across Wales are on the claimant count: claiming Universal Credit or Jobseeker's Allowance and looking for work. That is not the same as unemployment.
…
site-hours of storm-overflow discharge in Welsh Water's own 2024 return
across … sites. Hours are summed over sites, so many overflows spilling at once count many times. On average about 96 overflows were discharging at any moment.
Since you started reading: 0.00 site-hours of storm-overflow discharge, at the 2024 average rate An estimate: 844,375 hours ÷ 8,784 hours in 2024. Storms bunch the discharges, so it is an average, not a reading.

The energy in the sludge

Bubble size = spill hours in 2024, for the ten worst sites

27.5 GWhof heat from sludge digestion went unused in 2025-26. Welsh Water already makes 141.8 GWh of energy from its sludge, against a rough ceiling that we estimate at 190 GWh, so most of it is already caught. Heat is where the plainest waste is.
Made from sludge, all forms
141.8 GWh
Heat not used
27.5 GWh
Rough ceiling (our estimate)
190 GWh

Reported figures are Welsh Water's own. The ceiling is our estimate, low confidence and probably high. Question 4

Worst sites in 2024, by spill hours

Source: Welsh Water's 2024 event duration monitoring return.

Where it hurts most

In 2024, 287,576 properties in Wales, 19.46% of the total, were not on the gas grid: fifth of the eleven nations and regions of Great Britain, not the highest as we first said. Ceredigion, at 74.61%, is the highest of any mainland local authority. The areas furthest from the gas grid are rural, and rural areas are where the slurry is. Whether the two can be joined up is a question, not a finding. Question 6

Excellent Good Sufficient Poor Off the gas grid

Bathing water classifications are 2024's. Ring size = share of properties off the gas grid (DESNZ, 2024). Every local authority

AreaOff gridClaimantsBathing

Sorted by share off the gas grid. Claimants are the claimant count (ONS via Nomis), not unemployment. Bathing: the number of sites rated Poor, or Sufficient, in 2024.

Another company does it differently

Northumbrian Water

Sludge through advanced digestionits own claim100%
Welsh Water's, for comparisonreported98.2%
Average household billpublished£535
Welsh Water's, for comparisonpublished£683
Bioresources efficiency leadits own analysis32%
Jobs a year, whole £2.6bn programmeits projection3,000 jobs

These are Northumbrian's numbers and the published bills, not ours, and we have not checked the company's claims. Regional costs differ, so the bills do not show an effect of digestion. The first version of this site said Welsh Water was behind on digestion. It is not: the gap is small. The questions are about what happens next to the heat, the cake and the farm waste next door. Every number, with its source

What if Wales pulled together?

Welsh Water has no shareholders. What it spends, and any penalty it pays, comes from its customers: the people who live with the sewage. So the question is what that money buys.

Use the heat

27.5 GWh of heat from sludge went unused. Is there a customer for it? Question 4

Say which overflows, and when

£1.1bn is allowed for 2025-30, aiming for an average of 30 spills per overflow by 2029-30. Which overflows, and by when? Question 1

Work, honestly counted

Our estimate is 10–60 jobs, permanent, for every 100 farm digesters. Real, local, and not thousands. The working

Slurry out, cake back

Welsh Water's raw sludge is 3.1% solids; dairy slurry is 9%. If sludge can be carried to a digester, could slurry? Question 6

What we are asking

The first version of this site made demands, and some rested on claims that were wrong. So these are questions, each with the evidence for it. We will publish every answer, and every correction.

  1. Which storm overflows are being fixed, and when?

  2. Which outflows near bathing waters are disinfected?

  3. Where does the £44.72m go, and who ultimately pays?

  4. Why does heat from sludge digestion go unused?

  5. Why is energy self-sufficiency stuck below target?

  6. Could farm slurry go to Welsh Water's digesters, with the cake coming back?

  7. Is there a quicker win on the dairy farm than a digester?

  8. How is farm pollution found and stopped?

These are questions, not demands, and not a call to fine anyone. Welsh Water has no shareholders, so a fine is paid by its customers. What we want is for the money already being spent to go where it helps most, in the open.
Read the questions, with the evidence In numbers What changed, and why The original paper and model, kept